Three notable models stand out when comparing mini excavators: the Sany SY35U, New Holland E37C, and Bobcat E35. These machines each bring their own strengths to the table, making them suitable for different types of jobs and operators. Here we take a look at their main features to help determine which of these mini excavators available in Europe and around the world is best suited for different construction sites.
Bobcat E35
The Bobcat E35 is a well-known compact excavator that offers a zero tail swing design, which is useful in confined spaces. It has a 24.8 horsepower Kubota engine and an operating weight of 7,600 lbs. One aspect that sets the Bobcat apart is its quick track speed, allowing for faster movement across job sites. However, the machine is lighter compared to the other two models, which may affect its ability to penetrate tougher soils efficiently.
In terms of warranty, the Bobcat comes with a two-year or 2,000-hour coverage, which is shorter than the other excavators in this comparison. Maintenance can be somewhat challenging due to the placement of the oil filter, which is difficult to reach without laying down, making routine service a bit more cumbersome.
See also: How Portable Storage Units Support Construction Projects
New Holland E37C
The New Holland E37C is a slightly larger and more powerful machine than the Bobcat. With an operating weight of 8,300 lbs and 24.4 horsepower, it offers better digging power and stability. Like the Bobcat, it features a zero tail swing, which is useful in tight workspaces. Its operating efficiency is supported by a Yanmar engine, known for reliability.
In terms of warranty, the New Holland provides a two-year or 3,000-hour full machine limited warranty, giving it an edge over the Bobcat. While the New Holland offers strong digging performance, its serviceability is a bit more constrained. The access door only opens partway, requiring the operator to crouch when performing maintenance tasks. However, key components such as the oil and fuel filters are accessible from the top, improving convenience.
Sany SY35U
The Sany SY35U stands out for its digging performance and ease of maintenance. With an operating weight of 8,500 lbs and powered by a 23.3 horsepower Yanmar engine, this machine excels in providing strong breakout force, making it well-suited for challenging digging conditions. The Sany also offers a zero tail swing, allowing it to navigate tight spaces effectively.
One of the Sany’s key advantages is its industry-leading five-year or 5,000-hour warranty, offering long-term value and peace of mind for buyers. In terms of maintenance, the Sany is particularly user-friendly. The hood opens fully, and all essential components, including filters and fluid reservoirs, are easily accessible from the top, making routine service quick and straightforward.
Key Considerations
When choosing between these three machines, several factors come into play. The Bobcat E35 offers speed and agility, making it a good choice for operators needing to move quickly across job sites, although its lighter weight might limit its digging capabilities. The New Holland E37C provides a balanced mix of power and reliability, with a solid warranty and better digging performance than the Bobcat. However, maintenance accessibility could be improved.
The Sany SY35U shines in terms of digging power, durability, and ease of maintenance. With its superior warranty and strong breakout force, it is an excellent option for those seeking a long-lasting and high-performing mini excavator.
Ultimately, the best machine for your needs will depend on the specific requirements of your job site, but the Sany SY35U offers the most comprehensive package for digging power, maintenance convenience, and long-term value.
